In space, no one can hear your exposition.
After nearly 40 years, I don't need to tell you that Alien is a terrifying movie. A crew of people trapped on board a ship in space with a creepy, super quick and super powerful monster? Sign me up! And you know what, the sequels was also just as good too. Everything else afterwards... well at least Alien: Isolation was really good.
As great as the first two movies are, it's easy to forget that the Alien franchise has more crap in it than good. When Alien: Resurrection isn't the low point in your franchise's history (thank you Colonial Marines), then it's a miracle that people still hold the franchise in such reverence. It's the same as the Terminator movies; first two were good, then everything was shat upon in the attempt to make it a franchise, despite the plot not making any sense once it is a franchise. But like Terminator, Alien is able to survive and is still highly regarded for one reason; the main enemy is that memorable. The xenomorphs are just really cool, really awesome monsters. Everything about their design, the way they walk, the way they kill people, are all just really, really impressive.
BUT SAY! DID YOU EVER WANT TO KNOW WHERE THE XENOMORPHS CAME FROM?
Enter Prometheus, the 2012 prequel to the entire Alien franchise that split fans like no other film in the series. To say Prometheus was confusing would be an understatement, including Trilobytes, the Engineers, and muddling up all of the lore and atmosphere of the original movie. And for some reason, Prometheus had enough fans clamoring for more, so we now have Alien: Covenant, and it's so, so, so disappointing. It's not bad by any stretch of the word, but it's a whole lot of buildup for a whole lot of nothing.
Plot details aside... actually plot structure aside, I said that Covenant was a disappointing movie, but not a bad movie. To be fair, when you're directly following up the structural nightmare that was Prometheus, anything would be a step up. I wouldn't go and say that I was scared watching Covenant, but when there were some intense moments, they were intense. Chestbursters are still heart pounding to watch, and the first act's buildup is pretty sufficient. I only wish that the movie actually had payoff.
There's a ton of exposition on display here, and all of it doesn't really matter by the end of it. We see the Engineers, we see how xenomorphs came to be, but none of it really matters. And all of that info is towards the latter half of the movie. When Alien: Covenant is playing close to its chest, it's a solid Alien movie. Not as good as the first two mind you, but certainly on the same level as Alien 3. Once we know everything though, the xenomorphs lose a bit of their appeal. The mystery is solved about their origins, and while they're still frightening to watch as they dismember crew members, they lack that bit of the unknown.
Wow I'm doing a bad job at trying to say a few positive points about this movie and why it doesn't suck on toast. Ummm... Oh! The last scene is actually really interesting! Once the lame final twist occurs, it actually does leave a bit of an interesting ending. It's nothing mind blowing or anything like that, but it would make me want to see a direct sequel to Alien: Covenant because of it. A few new plot threads can be explored and to see where the franchise goes from there is somewhat compelling at least.
Other than that, yeah, Alien: Covenant is pretty mediocre. It's no sleigh ride of friendship from AvP, but it's inoffensive fluff that most fans are probably going to ignore. It makes more sense than Prometheus ever did, but Covenant doesn't contribute anything that's compelling about the Alien franchise. There's no cool action scenes, no claustrophobic scares, no memorable frights, and it more concerned with explaining the history of the franchise than actually delivering the scares of Alien or Aliens.
Ridley Scott went on record that he has ideas for four, yes four, more prequels to the Alien franchise, and while the next movie may be slightly more compelling because of its ending, please just make this a prequel trilogy. Prometheus was inept, Covenant was inoffensive, and if we can wring one more movie to close out the prequels, I would be totally fine with that. Just please make it more like the first half of this movie than the second half.
Hi everyone, before the usual Patreon post, I just wanted to make quick update and say that there will be no review next week. I'm heading off on vacation, and I don't want to try and cram in a review on a game I really want to talk about while I'm prepping to go away for a week or so. You'll still get Wonder Woman on the 4th, I'm just rescheduling Yooka Laylee for some other time. Maybe I'll trow up a quick something if I have time, but we'll just have to see. See you next time!
Hey everyone! Please consider donating to my Patreon, which can be found here. Spread the link and even if you can't donate, send a link to someone who may be interesting in reading critical reviews from a cynical man!